Category Archives: Comix

Comics Criticism

I posted these comments in response to some discussion at CBR’s Robot 6 about the recent creator-owned conversations and the tone of comics criticism. I’m posting this here because, as usual, some people have taken exception to my comments, although I don’t think there’s a thing here that should be controversial, unless you support general douchebaggery in comic reviewing. If I toss them up on the blog, I know where to reference them when people want to discuss them.

Here’s the piece I was responding to:

http://robot6.comicbookresources.com/2011/02/gorillas-riding-dinosaurs-the-comics-%E2%80%9Crevolution%E2%80%9D/

My response:

I’m not all that fond of negative criticism in online comics reviewing, period. Perhaps if I saw it handled more intelligently I’d be more inclined to be open-minded on the subject. But I don’t think criticism from most online reviewers is “constructive” in tone.

If you have the space to carefully examine a book and offer legitimate criticism, from a perspective that indicates to me that you have the knowledge and frames of reference from which to justify my time with your review, then, yes. Give me “serious criticism.” The problem is there aren’t many who are qualified or skilled enough to properly handle serious criticism.

Ironic that Steve sparked so much of this discussion. A couple of years back I was invited to discuss my thoughts on comics criticism by ifanboy. Josh Flanagan had written a rebuttal of sorts to a blog post of mine where I questioned the value of online comics criticism in its current form, and we “debated” the topic on the show.

The spark that ignited my initial blog post was a snarky, dismissive, and insulting review of a creator-owned book of Steve’s. The smug, holier than thou attitude of the reviewer (whomever it was) just pissed me off, knowing how hard Steve and his collaborators had no doubt worked on the book in question. I thought the efforts of the creators deserved more than smart-assed shredding by some faceless internet “personality.”

Anyway, if something isn’t your cup of tea, explain why you didn’t enjoy it, but please spare me your qualitative judgments, and, as Michael alludes to in this piece, spare me your snide or dismissive tone.

And, yes. Recommendations are always encouraged, assuming you make it clear why it appealed to you.

 

2 Comments

Filed under Comix

Robot 6 features my Timely sketchbook

Chris Arrant, of CBR’s Robot 6, spotlights my Timely sketchbook, which features pals of mine and their takes on Marvel’s crazy Golden Age characters:

http://robot6.comicbookresources.com/2010/09/themed-sketchbooks-b-clay-moores-timely-sketchbook/

Leave a comment

Filed under Comix

(Diana Prince) Wonder Woman #203

I just finished reading DC’s collected DIANA PRINCE WONDER WOMAN (VOLUME 4), which concludes the early 70s saga of Wonder Woman as a depowered “mod” gal who eschewed her costume for white slacks and shirts (generally).  By the time of these stories, Mike Sekowsky (who had initiated the run) was long gone, and the scripting was handled by Denny O’Neil and sci-fi writer Samuel R. Delany. The art was handled by Dick Giordano and Don Heck.

The O’Neil issues are standard early 70s silliness, highlighted by a Catwoman appearance (in her short-lived blue and red outfit), and dragged down by a lamebrained romantic subplot with roguish wisecracking private dick Jonny Double (who just vanishes in Delaney’s second issue). The first Delaney issue rather bizarrely introduces barbarians Fafhrd and the Grey Mouser (I couldn’t explain the plot to you if we had an entire weekend to do it), but the second issue (a SPECIAL! Women’s Lib Issue!) is kind of interesting.

The second Delany issue (sequenced in this trade paperback after a typically strange Bob Haney/Jim Aparo issue of THE BRAVE AND THE BOLD) is WONDER WOMAN #203, which, by coincidence, was the very first Wonder Woman comic I ever read when I was a kid. I think it must have come into my possession via a stack of old comics my dad brought home from work one day (a gift from a co-worker whose kids had long since outgrown comics). Anyway, I’d seen Wonder Woman in the Justice League, and on the Super Friends, so I knew what she looked like, and this chick in white wasn’t exactly her, so it always fascinated me. I’m sure I read the issue (I read every comic book I could get my hands on as a kid, no matter the content), but rereading it all these years later, not much of it was familiar.

I find it interesting because it’s clear that Delaney was attempting (presumably with editorial support) to push the book in a new direction. The story concerns Diana Prince being hired by a sinister department store to model their “women’s lib” clothes. She only realizes that she’s being used by male chauvinist pigs running the store when the local women’s lib organization hands her proof of their intentions, and also proof that the store is paying their female employees less than minimum wage (for some reason they have no male employees). Although, really, she probably should have known the department store (Grandee’s) was up to no good when the guy who showed up to offer her the job was the same guy who had harassed her on the street the night before because she blew off his sexist catcalls (before she kicked his ass with the help of a saucy blonde companion). The plot is a little complex and convoluted, but the story introduces some cast members who were clearly intended to stick around for a while, including a female black belt karate instructor and a female dog trainer with a handful of dobermans at her disposal. And Diana’s blind “Oriential” teacher, I-Ching, was still around, as he had been for the entire DPWW run.

The issue ends when a bunch of angry women barge into a Liberation meeting, angry that Diana and her bra-burning pals have put so many women out of work by shutting down the piggish department store. In the last panel, Diana looks at the reader and exclaims, “What do you say to them now? And will we have time? They look like they mean business!” Under her face is a caption that reads, “What will Diana do now?”

I have to say, as ham-fisted as much of the commentary was, the general thrust of the issue is unusual enough to make me curious exactly what Diana would do next. Dick Giordano always drew great women, and the mind conjures all kinds of crazy scenarios for Diana and her new pals to stumble into.  Hot-blooded libbers with rabid dogs and karate at their disposal?

Alas, it was not to be. The next issue (written by Robert Kanigher) completely ignores the question, and opens with a sniper randomly taking out innocent civilians, including, on page four, Diana’s mentor, I-Ching. Diana sheds a tear, hugs the “father she never had,” and never mentions him again. What follows is a ridiculos amnesia plot that sees her stealing a fighter jet and ending up back on Paradise Island. By the end of the issue, the hip, modern Diana Prince has been dispossessed in favor of the familiar golden lasso wrangler, complete with tiara and star spangled hot pants.  It’s one of the more abrupt dismissals of a concept I’ve seen, but I’m sure it was driven by sales, and as commendable as the effort might have been, it was no doubt doomed to fail from the word go.

An issue later WW was featured on the cover with her legs wrapped around a chubby phallic bomb, and it was business as usual once again. But I do wonder what Delany had in mind before he was kicked to the curb. And I give him a lot of credit for trying to address some of the issues concerning the women’s lib movement, even if the plot reduced every man in the story to a standard chauvinist.

2 Comments

Filed under Comix

The Losers

I already mentioned the Losers story I wrote.  I thought I’d pop one of my favorite original Losers covers up since I haven’t been posting a lot lately. I’m a huge fan of Joe Kubert’s covers for the series.

For what it’s worth, as much as I enjoy Jack Kirby’s Losers run, my story is more in the vein of the Robert Kanigher stories drawn by the great John Severin. Kirby seemed to have trouble embracing the notion that soldiers could be real “losers,” and took his stories in a different direction.

Oh, I just finished another small gig handling another old DC property. When that one’s solicited, I’ll probably share some of my favorite work associated with that character, too.

Leave a comment

Filed under Comix, My Projects

Favorite Graphic Novels

A visual walk through some of my all-time favorite trades/graphic novels.

hicksville

HICKSVILLE by Dylan Horrocks

goodlife

IT’S A GOOD LIFE IF YOU DON’T WEAKEN by Seth

concrete

THE COMPLETE CONCRETE by Paul Chadwick

watch

WATCHMEN by Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons

casanov

CASANOVA by Matt Fraction and Gabriel Ba

phoenix

X-MEN: THE DARK PHOENIX SAGA by John Byrne, Terry Austin and Chris Claremont

scalped

SCALPED VOL. 4: THE GRAVEL IN YOUR GUTS by Jason Aaron, R.M. Guera and pals

swamp

SAGA OF THE SWAMP THING, BOOK ONE by Alan Moore, Stephen Bissette and John Totleben

hate

HATE, VOL. 3: FUN WITH BUDDY AND LISA by Peter Bagge

animalman

ANIMAL MAN by Grant Morrison, Chas Truog and Dog Hazlewood

maus

MAUS by Art Spiegelman

rubber

STUCK RUBBER BABY by Howard Cruse

pussey

PUSSEY! by Daniel Clowes

next

NEXTWAVE: THIS IS WHAT THEY WANT by Warren Ellis and Stuart Immonen

assuper

ALL-STAR SUPERMAN, VOL. 1 by Grant Morrison and Frank Quitely

capote

CAPOTE IN KANSAS by Ande Parks and Chris Samnee

batsyer

BATMAN YEAR ONE by Frank Miller and David Mazzucchelli

jimmyc

JIMMY CORRIGAN: THE SMARTEST KID ON EARTH by Chris Ware

flagg

HOWARD CHAYKIN’S AMERICAN FLAGG! by Howard Chaykin

swatch

STORMWATCH: CHANGE OR DIE by Warren Ellis, Tom Raney and Oscar Jimenez

umbrella

THE UMBRELLA ACADEMY: APOCALYPSE SUITE by Gerard Way and Gabriel Ba

fell

FELL, VOLUME ONE by Warren Ellis and Ben Templesmith

bprd

B.P.R.D.: THE BLACK FLAME by Mike Mignola, John Arcudi and Guy Davis

pilgrim

SCOTT PILGRIM: PRECIOUS LITTLE LIES by Bryan Lee O’Malley

damn

THE DAMNED, VOLUME ONE by Cullen Bunn and Brian Hurtt

superspy

SUPER SPY by Matt Kindt

starman

STARMAN OMNIBUS, VOLUME ONE by James Robinson, Tony Harris and Wade Von Grawbadger

golden

THE GOLDEN AGE by James Robinson, Paul Smith and Richard Ory

dork

WHO’S LAUGHING NOW? (DORK, VOLUME ONE) by Evan Dorkin

jackstaff

JACK STAFF: EVERYTHING USED TO BE BLACK AND WHITE by Paul Grist

4 Comments

Filed under Comix

Six years and nine months later….

So, I was Googling words in an effort to name a new book I’m developing, and the tenth hit on Google was a link to Matt Fraction’s blog, which led me (circuitously) to his old Poplife column, from Comic Book Resources. Being easily distracted, I got caught up in Fraction’s circa 2002/2003 musings on comic book activism, and felt a weird little flood of nostalgia. There was this really brief time, when I was first working my way into comics, where I seemed to know a lot of people who were awfully concerned with the future of comics. It’s only been a little over six years since then, but in a lot of ways it feels like an eternity. If I only knew then…

Anyway, one of Fraction’s columns (from 12/02) referenced the first time I remember meeting him, in Hector Casanova’s then current studio/gallery/living space (The Green Door). Matt writes:

Peter, Kel, Xtop and myself managed to get together in a room with about 19 other young comics hopefuls in Kansas City this past weekend. It was really kind of fascinating. Steven Sanders brought his vintage Geiger counter. Hector let me look on his drawing table and I felt butterflies in my bones. B. Clay Moore showed up with a first look at his new book HAWAIIAN DICK, and it looks fantastic even if it printed too dark and too green (according to him). Hector and a guy named John Parker made it happen. There were two factions in the same place at the same time, the Art Institute kids like myself that were more into the gonzo, gung ho creation angle of things, the Art For Art’s Sake kinds, and the other half of the room were all, at first blush anyway, steel-eyed young professionals constructing elaborate cross-network opportunities and so forth. They were, on top of being creators, the organizers of expos and the senders-out of press releases. I had the feeling that if both halves of the room came together, everyone would walk out a whole lot smarter.

The meeting, as I recall, was partly in the service of bringing together factions of the then emerging Kansas City comic scene to help put together a comic art show (which we actually did). I also recall Fraction wore a Santa Claus hat the whole time. In retrospect, I never considered myself a “steel-eyed young professional,” and at the time saw HAWAIIAN DICK as a small blow for art as commerce (at the time, okay? At the time).  Of course, more and more I find I’m starving myself in an insane effort to straddle the fence between commerce and creation, and Matt has obviously moved (for now) squarely into the crosshairs of commercial creation, albeit only after crafting CASANOVA, which is perhaps the ultimate example of genre-as-art.

The late, lamented Green Door

Fraction’s left Kansas City (on the heels of Tony Moore and Harold Sipe), and I’ve lost touch with a lot of the gang I used to raise a fist for comics with, but it’s probably a good idea to jog the memory of those days when the simple idea of Making Comics was new and exciting.

Now I need to get back to — you know — actually making comics.

3 Comments

Filed under Comix